1824 Fogarty Avenue, Key West, FL 33040 (MLS# 617165)

1824 Fogarty Avenue, Key West, FL 33040

$1,350,000

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 6 Baths: 7 Square Footage: 2,398 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 9,483 Status: Contingent/Show

Current Price: $1,350,000 List Date: 11/03/2025 Last Modified: 12/10/2025

Description

This 4-unit tropical compound spans nearly 9,500 sq. ft. and includes a spacious 3BD/3.5BA main home plus three charming 1BD/1BA cottages. Enjoy resort-style living with a pool, tiki bar, and lush outdoor space. This property offers flexibility for employee housing, long-term rentals, or a 'Key West Melrose Place'-style retreat. Centrally located near beaches, dining, and Old Town—live and earn in paradise!

More Information MLS# 617165

Contract Information

Listing Board: Key West Association As is Rght to Inspct: Yes Species List: No Current Price: $1,350,000 Listing Date: 2025-11-03 List Price: $1,350,000

Location, Tax & Legal

KW Neighborhood: Midtown East City: KEY WEST Off Shore Island: No Mile Marker: 3 Marathon Neighborhood: N/A Side: Median Flood Zone: AE Alternate Key #: 1050156 Parcel #: 00049560-000000 Zoning: SF - Single Family Deed Restrictions: No Legal: KW KW REALTY COS FIRST SUB PB1-43 LOTS 11 AND 12 SQR 35 TR 21 G10-529 G11-539 G68-461 OR453-689 OR876-744 OR918-1313 OR9 Taxes: 10032.73 Tax Year: 2024 Pub Sewer HkUp: Yes Street #: 1824 Street Name: Fogarty Street Suffix: Avenue Key/Island: Key West State/Province: FL Zip Code: 33040 County: Monroe Subdivision: Key West Realty Cos Sub (3.0) Area: 03 - Key West

General Property Description

Realtor.COM Type: Multi-family Waterfront: No Control Depth: 0 Lot SqFt: 9483 Pool: Yes Lot Sqft Source: Property Data Card Total Units: 4 Acres: 0.22 SqFt Source: Property Data Card Rentals Allowed: With Restrictions Min Rental Days: 28 Style: Multi-Units Year Built: 1950 Living Apx SqFt: 2398 Total Bedrooms: 6 Full Baths: 7 Total Baths: 7

Remarks & Misc

Remarks – Consumer: This 4-unit tropical compound spans nearly 9,500 sq. ft. and includes a spacious 3BD/3.5BA main home plus three charming 1BD/1BA cottages. Enjoy resort-style living with a pool, tiki bar, and lush outdoor space. This property offers flexibility for employee housing, long-term rentals, or a 'Key West Melrose Place'-style retreat. Centrally located near beaches, dining, and Old Town—live and earn in paradise! Directions: Located on Fogarty Avenue between 1st & George Streets.

Association Info

Mandatory Home Owners Asc: No 1st Right of Refusal: No Association Fee $: 0

Fee Includes

None: 1

Dockage

None: 1

Tax Exemptions

Homestead: 1

Appliances

Oven: 1 Refrigerator: 1

Pets

Pets Allowed: 1

Cooling

Wall/Window Unit(s): 1

Heating

None: 1

Waterfront

None: 1

Waterview

No Waterview: 1

Property Condition

Fixer Upper: 1

Building Style

Above Flood: Unknown

Windows/Doors

Aluminum Windows: 1 Single Hung Windows: 1

Construction

Frame: 1

Land Size

Less Than 1/4 Acre: 1

Furnished

Unfurnished: 1

Utilities

Buyer to Verify: 1

Porch/Balcony

Patio: 1

Title

Title Ins - Buyer: 1

Exterior Features

Bar: 1 Chickee Hut: 1 Detached Guest Qtrs: 1 Fencing: 1 Outdoor Kitchen: 1 Privacy Wall/Fence: 1

Pool Info

In Ground: 1

Accessibility Feat

None: 1

Shutters

Other: 1

Status Change Info

Contingent: Contingent/Show Status: Contingent/Show

Property Features

Fee Includes: None Tax Exemptions: Homestead Waterfront: None Waterview: No Waterview Dockage: None Property Condition: Fixer Upper Furnished: Unfurnished Cooling: Wall/Window Unit(s) Heating: None Utilities: Buyer to Verify Appliances: Oven; Refrigerator Exterior Features: Bar; Chickee Hut; Detached Guest Qtrs; Fencing; Outdoor Kitchen; Privacy Wall/Fence Accessibility Feat: None Pool Info: In Ground Construction: Frame Shutters: Other Pets: Pets Allowed Land Size: Less Than 1/4 Acre Title: Title Ins - Buyer

Listing Office: eXp Realty LLC

Last Updated: December - 10 - 2025

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Florida Keys MLS, Inc. Information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commeral use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. IDX data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.